Skip navigation
The Lobster Press
<p>The Lobster Press sandwich at Marc Forgione&#39;s Lobster Press at the Pennsy food hall in New York.</p>

Marc Forgione goes casual

&bull; See more Owner Interviews

Marc Forgione might be best-known for his Michelin-starred Restaurant Marc Forgione, as well as his successful turns on the Food Network’s The Next Iron Chef and Iron Chef America, but the chef-restaurateur (a 2008 Restaurant Hospitality Rising Star) is turning his attention to a different arena: fast casual.

Marc Forgione
Forgione, known for his Michelin stars, is trying a casual concept. Photo: Marc Forgione

​Forgione is following in the footsteps of many other big-name chefs who have tested the casual waters. They include Rick Bayless, Richard Blais, Bobby Flay, Jose Andres and others. Last month in St. Louis, James Beard winner Gerard Craft opened a Chipotle-style Italian concept, Porano Pasta.

Forgione’s take is a lobster panini concept at the new Pennsy food hall at Penn Plaza, near Penn Station and Madison Square Garden. Pennsy is a small, upscale collection of chef-driven concepts. Forgione’s Lobster Press concept operates alongside Mario Batali and Mary Giuliani’s Mario by Mary, Pat LaFriedea Meat Purveyors and well-known vegan chef Franklin Becker’s The Little Beet. Popular NYC food truck the Cinnamon Snail has also opened its first bricks-and-mortar location at Pennsy.

“I came to work one Monday over the summer and got a call from [the developer of] Pennsy asking if I wanted to do something there, but there were restrictions, like I couldn’t have a hood and I couldn’t do meat,” recounts Forgione, as Pat LaFreida was already onboard with a meatball and filet mignon sandwiches concept.

It was while Forgione was kicking around ideas for a concept at Pennsy that lobster purveyor Homarus called and pitched an idea for a lobster sandwich. That conversation inspired the Lobster Press concept. “The whole thing was chance or fate, whatever you want to call it,” recalls Forgione. 

Whatever the reason, Forgione, busy expanding his full-service restaurant portfolio with a third location of his steakhouse American Cut, says he was excited to be in the kitchen and experimenting with sandwiches. The hot lobster panini plays off the popular Chili Lobster dish at Restaurant Marc Forgione.

The labor-intensive process starts with live lobsters, caught on Homarus’s small boats along the coast of Northeast Maine and delivered to Lobster Press at Pennsy three times per week. The lobsters are cooked each morning, and each sandwich contains about a whole lobster—is 1 lb. of tail, knuckle and claw meat mixed with scallions, chilies, mint and celery, pressed between sliced, buttered ciabatta, and served with a side of chili lobster dipping sauce (made with lobster stock, sriracha and lime juice) that  Forgione created for the concept. A full sandwich menus for $17;  a half-press is $9. Forgione’s crew also makes lobster bisque every day, and Lobster Press menus a bisque-and-grilled-cheese combo for $13.

Lobster Press is located just a few feet from The Bar at the Pennsy and Forgione and his team are contributing to a menu of bar snacks, namely, grilled cheese fingers and the whimsical Lobster-in-a-Blanket, where lobster meat is baked in puff pastry.

Forgione says more “on-the-go spots” are planned for Manhattan, although he’s not talking specifics yet. “I’d love to be able to do as many as we possibly can,” says Forgione. “It’s built for multiple venues. I’m open to any kind of location; stadiums, on a dock somewhere, anywhere I see fast food now.”

Expansion is requiring to Forgione to delegate. Cary Goldberg (former bar manager at Restaurant Marc Forgione) and Marc Forgione chef Chance Perkins are running the day-to-day operations at Lobster Press. (The latter, a sandwich lover, creates a special daily sandwich, cleverly named “Take a Chance,” that doesn’t include lobster.)

Despite his reputation for attention to detail, Forgione says he’s comfortable delegating as he adds more restaurants  to his portfolio. “It’s a testament to the people I hire,” says the son of An American Place founder Larry Forgione. “The only way to grow is to have multiple venues, and you have to trust the people you work with. I’m only as good as they are.”

Forgione likes the food hall idea and the way he and his peers are helping fast food to evolve. “I think and I hope [concepts like Lobster Press are] the future of fast food. In general, [fast food] is bad, although it’s not like I’ve never eaten a Big Mac. Bad for you, bad ingredients, not done with care or with the environment in mind,” Forgione says. “If you get chefs and restaurateurs and people who care about what they’re feeding people, that should be future of fast food.”

Contact Gina Ragone at [email protected]
Follow her on Twitter: @RagoneGina

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.