Skip navigation
Best Sandwiches in America 2015: Fish

Best Sandwiches in America 2015: Fish

Who makes the best sandwich? Restaurant Hospitality’s editorial staff narrowed down the large field in our Best Sandwiches in America contest to 18 finalists. See all winners >>

Winner: Wild Salmon Reuben

Restaurant: Elliott’s Oyster House, Seattle

Sandwich Creator: Robert Spaulding

Inspiration: “I’ve always had a passion for pastrami, sauerkraut and salmon. I put the flavors together.”

Key Ingredients: Cured and smoked northwest salmon, apple and red cabbage sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, house Russian, thick-cut rye

Price: $17

Food Cost: $4.50

What the Judges Said: This year and last, folks entered a seafood-style Reuben, but none used fish this pristine and then applied a pastrami brine and rub before caressing it in light smoke. It has made all the difference. The salmon could live alone in this sandwich, but Spaulding pairs it with terrific house-made kraut and Russian. He’s going to get a high-five the next time we see him. It’s no wonder Zagat named the Wild Salmon Reuben one of “Seattle’s nine most spectacular sandwiches of 2014.”

Honorable Mentions:
• Grilled Halibut: Public House, Chicago
• Seared Ahi Tuna: Masterpiece Delicatessen, Denver
• Lucciopanino: Piccolo Sogno Due, Chicago
• The Bay on the Bun: Ocean Odyssey, Cambridge, MD
• Cornmeal-Dusted Oyster Slider: Blossom, Charleston, SC

Next: Vegetarian
Previous: Duck

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.